Culture & heritage · 7 picks · Updated

Gifts Your Nonna Will Only Mildly Critique

Is it sauce or gravy? Doesn't matter, because Nonna's is better than yours and she will tell you so, lovingly, while making a second pot. This list is for the Sunday-dinner traditionalists, the Feast of the Seven Fishes planners and anyone who keeps a butter cookie tin full of sewing supplies. Gifts that respect the recipes (and survive the critique).

Every pick links to Amazon for the current price. How we choose. We may earn a commission from links. Disclosure.

Italian American Sunday dinner table with fresh pasta drying on a rack, a hand-crank pasta machine, a pot of red sauce and a moka pot
AI illustration (Higgsfield), styled for inspiration. Not the exact products.

The picks

No. 01Amazon

Marcato Atlas 150 Pasta Machine (Made in Italy)

The made-in-Italy pasta machine that makes Sunday dinner a two-hour family affair, as intended.

Real-life use: Fresh lasagna sheets, fettuccine and tagliolini from scratch.

Check price on Amazon
No. 02Amazon

Bialetti Moka Express Stovetop Espresso Maker (6-Cup)

The octagonal pot your grandparents had, and your grandkids will too.

Real-life use: Stovetop espresso after Sunday dinner, with or without a splash of anisette.

Check price on Amazon
No. 03Amazon

KneadEat Wooden Gnocchi Board

Ridges, so the sauce (sorry, gravy) has something to hold onto.

Real-life use: Gnocchi and cavatelli with the classic ridges, made at the kitchen table.

Check price on Amazon
No. 04Amazon

TACGEA Ravioli Stamp Set with Cutter Wheel

For whoever gets assigned ravioli duty on Christmas Eve. Every year. Forever.

Real-life use: Stamp and seal ravioli in four shapes; the wheel trims the edges.

Check price on Amazon
No. 05Amazon

Mutti Whole Peeled Tomatoes (28 oz, 6-Pack)

A case of tomatoes, for the person who judges a household by its pantry.

Real-life use: Sunday gravy, Saturday pizza sauce and a big pot of minestrone.

Check price on Amazon
No. 06Amazon

Cambom Rotary Cheese Grater

Table-side cheese grating, because “say when” should be a negotiation.

Real-life use: Fresh parm at the table; also shreds nuts and chocolate.

Check price on Amazon
No. 07Amazon

GoSports 100 mm Regulation Bocce Set

Regulation bocce, plus a measuring rope to settle arguments. (Arguments will not be settled.)

Real-life use: Backyard games at summer parties, beach days and family reunions.

Check price on Amazon

Pairs Well With: Ready-Made Bundles

Pairs well with

Sunday Gravy Starter Pack

Tomatoes, cheese and the coffee to finish.

  1. AmazonMutti Whole Peeled Tomatoes (28 oz, 6-Pack)
    Check price
  2. AmazonCambom Rotary Cheese Grater
    Check price
  3. AmazonBialetti Moka Express Stovetop Espresso Maker (6-Cup)
    Check price

Pairs well with

Pasta Night Workshop

The machine, the board, the stamps.

  1. AmazonMarcato Atlas 150 Pasta Machine (Made in Italy)
    Check price
  2. AmazonKneadEat Wooden Gnocchi Board
    Check price
  3. AmazonTACGEA Ravioli Stamp Set with Cutter Wheel
    Check price
Pinterest graphic: Gifts Your Nonna Will Only Mildly Critique

Save it for later

Pin this list

Saving ideas for later, or sending a not-so-subtle hint? Pin it or share it with the group chat.