Your least favorite people · 8 picks · Updated

Gifts for the Secret Santa You Regret Drawing

You unfolded the slip, read the name and felt your soul leave your body. It's fine. You don't need to know them well. You need a gift that's fun to open, easy to like and safe for a crowded room. These are crowd-pleasers with a wink, all of them good enough that nobody will suspect how you really felt about that slip of paper.

Every pick links to Amazon for the current price. How we choose. We may earn a commission from links. Disclosure.

Holiday table with wrapped gifts, a bowl of candy, a folded name card and a small Christmas tree
AI illustration (Higgsfield), styled for inspiration. Not the exact products.

The picks

No. 01Amazon

Exploding Kittens Card Game (Original Edition)

A game about avoiding disaster. Very on-theme for how you felt when you drew their name.

Real-life use: Fast rounds for the break room, game night or the office holiday party.

Check price on Amazon
No. 02Amazon

Pop Chart 100 Essential Movies Scratch-Off Poster

100 movies to scratch off. That's a lot of nights they won't be making small talk with you.

Real-life use: A bucket-list poster for movie lovers that slowly turns into wall art.

Check price on Amazon
No. 03Amazon

Rubik's Cube, the Original 3x3

Something to keep their hands busy during your next conversation.

Real-life use: A classic brain teaser for desks, commutes and long phone calls.

Check price on Amazon
No. 04Amazon

"World's Okayest Employee" Mug

Warm, honest and legally a compliment.

Real-life use: A desk mug for coffee, tea or pens. HR approved, probably.

Check price on Amazon
No. 05Amazon

The New York Times Strictly Medium Crossword Puzzles, Vol. 1

200 puzzles. That's at least 200 lunch breaks of peace.

Real-life use: Medium-difficulty crosswords for lunch breaks, flights and lazy Sundays.

Check price on Amazon
No. 06Amazon

Burt's Bees Classics Gift Set (6 Products in a Tin)

The gift that says “I thought about you” without you having to.

Real-life use: A tin of balms and lotions for dry office air and winter hands.

Check price on Amazon
No. 07Amazon

Lindt LINDOR Holiday Assorted Truffles Gift Box

Universally loved, impossible to misread and festive enough to look effortful.

Real-life use: Holiday truffles to share, re-gift or keep in a desk drawer.

Check price on Amazon
No. 08Amazon

Taco vs Burrito Card Game

A card game. A loud one. Let them be someone else's problem at the party.

Real-life use: Quick, chaotic rounds for family gatherings and office parties.

Check price on Amazon

Pairs Well With: Ready-Made Bundles

Pairs well with

The Under-the-Radar Crowd-Pleaser

Fun to open, safe in a crowded room, zero emotional investment required.

  1. AmazonExploding Kittens Card Game (Original Edition)
    Check price
  2. AmazonLindt LINDOR Holiday Assorted Truffles Gift Box
    Check price
  3. Amazon"World's Okayest Employee" Mug
    Check price
Pinterest graphic: Gifts for the Secret Santa You Regret Drawing

Save it for later

Pin this list

Saving ideas for later, or sending a not-so-subtle hint? Pin it or share it with the group chat.